2022
• Michael Houge - Saint Peter's Univesity
• Elijah Davis - University of the Incarnate Word
• Wade Pelfrey - University of Pikeville
• Ty Hurst - Tennessee Wesleyan
2021
- Tylar Haynes - Quachita Baptist University
- Sly Thompson - Blue Mountain College
2020
- Paris Taylor - Univerity of Green Bay
- Kobe Powell - Texas A&M Texarkana
- Luis Machado - Southwest Christian Oklahoma
- Tyler Arnold - Emory and Henry College
2019
• Miles Thomas - University of Tennessee Martin
• Demontay Dixon - Evansville University
• Khiry Shelton - Hampton University
• Kajuan Hale - California Baptist University
• Seth Battle - Bluefield College
2018
• Malik McConnell - Life University
• Elijah Cooper - Townsend University
• Alfonzo Peoples - Indiana Southeast University
• Eric Turner - Arkansas Tech University
• Randal Broddie - Tarleton State University
• Tyree Beason - Blue Mountain College
• Dajuonta Ross - Blue Mountain College
• Jean Michael Tine - Benedict College
2017
- Brandon Goldsmith – North Carolina Central University
- DeMonte Evans – Lincoln University
- Chase Nappier – Bethel University
- Braxton Nappier – Bethel University
- Ricky Dunnaway – Tennessee Technology University
- Andrew Roker – Vorhees University
2016
- Jalen Oliver – Tennessee Wesleyan
- Denzel Smith – Tarlton University
- Karem Wright – Gramblen State University
- Corey Nelson – Young Harris University
- Will Smith – Martin Medithos College
- Johnny Fox – Robert Morris
2015
- Benard Williams – Columbus State University
- Osmond Robinson – Piedmont University
- Filipp Burnashov – Frances Marion
- Marcellus Roberts – Young Harris University
- Stetson Moore – East Tennessee State University
- Brandon Walters – Middle Tennessee State University
- Alex Hicks – Troy State University
2014
- Cameron High – Lee University
- Aaron Wheeler – Charleston Southern University
- Trey Suttles – Tennessee Wesleyan
- Vincent Brown – Tusculum
- Elgrin Wilson – Lee University
2013
- Leland Robinson – TWC
- Jeff Simpson – Virginia Intermont
- Tyler Ailshie – ETSU
2012
- Lamar McKnight – Florida Southern
- Cyrille Sandjon – University of Faulkner
- Julito Hutchinson – St. Catherine
2011
- Desmond Crisp – TWC
- Addison Flynn – Tusculum
- Sabastian Ginapp – Emory & Henry
2010
- Trey Payne – Cumberland University
- Kyle Upton – Cumberland University
- John Holman – Carson Newman
- Lequantis Stewart – Martin Methodist
2009
- Michael Jenkins – Mercer University
- Chris Talley – Fairmont State (WV)
- Andrew Suggs – Clafflin University (SC)
- Rande Sibley – University of Tennessee Chattanooga
2008
- Reggie Shaw – Virginia Intermont
- Sirlester Martin – Youngstown State
- Kyle Donahue – Milligan
- Freeman Pinkney – Martin Methodist
2006
- Adron Marshall – Mountan States (WV)
- Ralph Legg – Mountan States (WV)
- Patrick Youmessi – Carson-Newman
- Zach Hyatt – Carson-Newman
2005
- Lamont Campbell – Lambuth University
- D.D. Golden – Lambuth University
- Darryl Sommerset – Central Missouri State
- Wadale Williams – Central Missouri State
- Marquese Crockette – Cumberland University
- Thomas Haynes – Bethel College
- James Helton – Fairmont State (WV)
- Auramas Silys – Anderson College (SC)
2004
- Jerry Nichols – Arkansas State University
- Cris Clapp – Cumberland College
- Larr McNeal – Lane University
- Christian Simmons – Cumberland College
- LaShon Sheffield – Tarlton State University
2003
- Corey Wade – Bluefield College
- Jamaine Burcke – Bluefield College
- Quinton Thompson – Lane University
- Adam Ruffin – University of West Alabama
- Josh Walker – Southern Wesleyan University
2002
- Larry Coleman – Carson Newman College
- Jason Williams – North Dakota State University
2001
- Alex Kragel – University of North Carolina at Asheville
- Josh Roark – Tennessee Tech University
- Travis Moreloc – Bethel College
- Gary Long – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
- Jason Williams – Tusculum College
- Kevin Bonner – Lane University
- Daniel Sterbinz – Western Florida University
2000
- Hamler, A.J. – Millligan
- Berford Whitson – Cumberland University
1999
- Tehran Gary – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
- Marcus Mason – Middle Tennessee State University
1998
- Jason Walker – Lee's McRae University
- Bart Crain – Milligan College
1997
- Mark Smith – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
- Ryan Osborne – Lincoln Memorial University
- Brad Eldridge – Martin Methodist University
- Trent Stewart – Carson-Newman College
- Robert Fears – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
1996
- William Foster – Virginia Intermont
- Travis Sensabaugh – Gardner Webb
- Josh McDaniel – University of Virginia-Wise
1995
- Matt Padgett – Troy State University
- T.C. Willis – Lincoln Memorial University
- Chuck Babb – Union College
- Mark Tate – Lee University
- Micky Swafford – Cumberland University
- Jason Davis – Milligan College
1993
- Darrell Miller – Central Wesleyan
- Micky Stewart – Lincoln Memorial University
- Jermaine Johnson – Maryville College
- Rusty Wilson – Maryville College
- Aaron Matthews – Eastern Kentucky University
- Tyler Stockman – Carson-Newman College
- Shea Wilkerson – Carson-Newman College
1992
- Brian Griffith – University South Carolina Spartanburg
- Darrell Middleton – Cumberland University
1991
- Milton Dean – Middle Tennessee State Unversity
- Ron Wilson – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
- Steve Curtis – King College
- William Holmes – Eastern Kentucky University
- Paul Wallace – McNeese State University
1990
- Loren Riddick – East Tennessee State University
- Lorenzo Johnson – Bluefield College
- Bart Walker – Lincoln Memorial University
- Scott Hensley – Lincoln Memorial University
1989
- Mark Mynatt – University South Carolina Spartanburg
- Travis Ward – Tennessee Wesleyan
1988
- Terry Steward – Bristol College
- Tim Thompson – Bristol College
- Scott Williams – Marshall University
- Anthony Warren – University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
- Brad Thelen – Virginia Intermont
- Robbie Jackson – University of Arkansas - Pine Bluff
1987
- Jeffery Isbell – Carson-Newman College
1986
- Allan Swader – Carson-Newman College
- David Roach – Birmingham Southern
1985
- Ronnie Carter – LEE's University
- Ensley Wolfenburger – Lincoln Memorial University
- Greg Davis – Mercer University
- Randy Harbin – Lincoln Memorial University
- Elston Beal – Tennessee Wesleyan
1983
- Charles Bates – University of Alabama-Huntsville
- Mark Cox – Livingston College
- Quentin Ashford – Carson-Newman College
- Allan Sharpe – Tusculum College
- Toby Howell – Lincoln Memorial University
- Jerry Burnette – Lincoln Memorial University
1982
- Chris Coach – Carson-Newman College
1981
- Kevin Ward – Milligan College
- Michael Rogers – Tusculum College
- Steve Peck – Carson-Newman College
- Steve Cunningham – Carson-Newman College
- Gary Lowrance – Knoxville College
1980
- Randy Smith – Concordia College
1979
- Michael Williams – Tennessee Technological University
- AndreBryant – Kent State University
- Jamie Dickson – Tusculum College
- Kenny Adams – Tusculum College
- David McWilliams – Tusculum College
- Cary Jenkins – Averett College
- Richard Hitch – Maryville College
1978
- Rex Shepard – Tusculum College
1976
- Dan Anderson – Birmingham Southern
- Kenny Teffeteller – University of Tennessee
- Terry Rutherford – Western Carolina
- Chuck Ogle – Maryville College
- Quitman Bohanan – University of Arkansas - Pine Bluff
1975
- Gary Meredith – Delta State University
- Edd Williams – Delta State University